Coffee is wildly unpredictable. How unpredictable? You go to a café and have a really good cup of beans. You come back next time — same beans, same barista — and chances are it tastes completely different. Not as good. Maybe even bad. Or worse, it never tastes good again. I’ve been through this myself more times than I can count. Even top-tier cafés are guilty of this. It drives you absolutely insane.
Once I was at a café I know well, sitting at the bar. The barista brewed a pour-over, took a sip, and immediately dumped the entire carafe. I asked what happened. He said, “Didn’t brew it right. Starting over.” And that’s a café I know, a barista I know — someone with solid skills and years of experience. At most other places, they’d just serve it to you anyway. How can you expect consistency? How can you expect consistently high quality?

At a lot of cafés — even ones owned by industry heavyweights, competition-winning baristas — the big names aren’t behind the bar day to day. They hire baristas, and many of them are just ordinary workers, sometimes even total rookies. I was once at a well-known café and ordered a Gesha mystery box. The barista drew one and was about to brew it. I asked which bean I’d gotten. She said she didn’t know, couldn’t tell from the bag. I was a bit shocked. I asked to see it — turns out it was a Panama Abu Gesha. She apologized and said she’d just started recently, wasn’t very familiar with the beans, and might not brew it well. I thought to myself, great, there goes my money. And sure enough, the cup was thoroughly mediocre. What a waste.
On top of that, baristas have notoriously high turnover. Swap out one barista and the café’s entire brewing style and quality shift. That’s why café offerings are so inconsistent — and so frustrating.
Drinking coffee is a complete gamble — like opening a mystery box every single time.